I’m down to my final week here in Istanbul, and I find the
prospect of departing for parts unknown (or known, whatever) exceptionally
bittersweet. I’ve missed you all a great deal while I have been gone, but this
is city and country whose people are so vibrant and festive and welcoming, it
will be hard to leave them. I’ll give you one last travel story to explain what
I mean.
I spent last weekend
in Izmir with my first ever Turkish teacher, Ferdane Denkçi, her husband Süleyman
and her mother. I arrived early in the morning on a Saturday, but Süleyman was
still there at the bus station to pick me up. Ferdane was at home preparing a
massive and delicious Turkish breakfast for me to eat upon arrival. They then
packed up everything and prepared, assuring me that all I needed to do was “Sit
comfortably”. Ok. If you insist. They took me to the beach for the day and out
for dinner. Probably one of the most difficult things, if not the most
difficult, about being gone from home for an extended period of time is feeling
like you are no longer a member of a family. I feel the most homesick when I’m
traveling, getting into the airport and everyone is there with a sign and a
name and I walk past, catching the next bus, to catch the next ferry etc etc
until I arrive alone at my dorm room. I love the independence that being here
has given me, but I do miss having someone waiting for me. Izmir was a
wonderful reminder that I am part of many families, and that even though I may
not see all of my far flung relatives very often, we still care for each other.
Ferdane’s mother embraced me as a full member of the family within about 20
minutes of meeting me. She invited me to visit her in Istanbul, wanted to take
pictures with me as well as Ferdane in Kuşadası after our lovely day of relaxation, and the next day at
Kemeraltı, the shopping district in Izmir, introduced me to shopkeepers as her
daughter. One poor shopgirl kept looking from Ferdane to me, and finally said,
“Are you really sisters?” at which
point we laughed and explained the relationship. The shopping trip was very
successful and I was pretty popular overall. Izmir does not get nearly as many
tourists as Istanbul and very few of them speak Turkish. Even fewer go to
Kemeraltı, which isn’t a tourist market. It’s where you go to get some new
towels, a tea pot and some fake Converse. Every time I opened my mouth and
Turkish came out, everyone was ridiculously pleased. I felt vaguely like a
performing animal, but perhaps they enjoy the praise too. I felt fully immersed
and engaged in the Turkish culture, integrated into the fabric of life here.
Süleyman asked me Sunday evening after our mangal, or
barbeque, what the biggest difference was between Turkish and American culture
is. I had to stop and think for a moment, but then I knew. Americans can be
incredibly time oriented and often are in our everyday interactions with
strangers. Turkish people aren’t. The focus is always on the person. This
probably contributes to everything being late all the time, but all attention
is focused on whoever is being worked with, rather than the 20 appointments
afterwards, which I do appreciate (except when I’m waiting).
Case in point, on the bus to Izmir, or more specifically at
Alibeyköy bus stop in Istanbul, I got to witness a rather interesting cultural
event and how Turks are focused on the person, rather than the clock. I was
sitting waiting for my bus to arrive and I notice a couple of young men arrive
doubled or tripled up on motorbikes, making quite a racket, trying to pull
tricks etc. Then a tiny van pulls up, unloads like it’s a clown car, and they
start blasting music. In this particular case it’s Thrift Shop by Macklemore,
which makes me laugh, because American pop music is everywhere. I’m trying to figure out what the heck is
going on, because really, I wouldn’t pick the bus stop for my Friday night rave
with my friends. All of them are pretty loud, singing and chatting. They’ve
gotten out some fireworks too. For a couple moments, I’m a little nervous,
wondering if rather than a rave, this is going to collapse into a riot. They
seem pretty happy for a riot though, and it’s a mixed crowd at the bus station
at 11pm so I don’t know what they would be protesting about. Then they start
tossing one of their group up into the air and catching him. I’m worried for
his safety, because some of his compatriots seem more than a little bit drunk,
but nothing happens. Then the crowd around me starts talking, they finally know
what’s up. The young man in question is leaving for askerlik, or his 2 year
required military service. Every man in Turkey does it at some point and now is
this young guy’s turn. He’s on my bus as it turns out. His friends crowd around
the door and sing a song to him as he gets on, joking and laughing with him
until the last possible moment. He’s about my age, I’d say, but the new recruit
looks younger than that and a little deer in the headlights, as though he’s not
sure what he’s going to do away from home for two years. There is something
sweetly naïve about him. We pull out from the berth and I think that’s that,
but his friends have arranged themselves at the exit, sitting on each other’s
shoulders. The bus driver calls the young man up to the front, and he stands at
attention while his friends sing to him one last time, lighting fireworks and
unfurling a Turkish flag with Ataturk superimposed on it, the founder and
protector of the republic. The bus and the entire bus station stop and wait
while this young man’s friends, who number a good 2 dozen, give him a real
send-off. Everyone was willing to wait, because this was both an important and
terrifying part of this young man’s life. Everyone understood it and accepted
it and our patience was our contribution to his send-off, to let him know that
his sacrifice is appreciated. A few days
before a bomb had gone off in Reyhanlı Turkey, killing 50 people at a market and the dialogue with Syria
is spiraling out of control, so this young man may indeed have sacrifices to
make. But for the night his friends just want to wish him well.
Süleyman told me after I mentioned this dichotomy between the
States and Turkey (and I’m not saying that people aren’t important to other
people in America, but we value punctuality often above building relationships,
it’s a difference in what is construed as rude and acceptable), that I was
doing important work. He caught me a little off-guard, but I was glad that he
said it to me. I try to explain sometimes the incredible importance of being a
cultural ambassador in other parts of the world, and representing not just
women or MSU students but also Americans when I travel. Most Turks have never
had a real conversation with an American, and so my job is to win hearts and
minds with my broken Turkish, my quiet demeanor and my attitudes towards
laughter love and life. I do my best, but it’s good to hear that what I do, and
what I want to do with a great deal more of my life does make an impact. To
hear it from Süleyman’s lips confirmed for me what I’ve always felt in my gut:
it is valuable work and there aren’t enough people doing it.
Another interesting point about the weekend, it was Turkish
only. Every interaction I had for more than 48 hours was in Turkish. I spoke
Turkish with Ferdane and her family, on the bus, with waiters and vendors and
all the rest. And I did pretty well for myself. I hadn’t seen Ferdane for
almost 2 years, so she and Süleyman were blown out of the water by my
improvement in Turkish, which was incredibly affirming for me. Earlier in the
week I had my first experience where I listened to Turkish and understood it,
but it didn’t register as a foreign language. This is a strange and wonderful
feeling once you realize that it’s happened, because you know that your mind
has completed all the circuits and your brain has accepted this new tongue into
the fold. I’ve had it happen in Spanish, but never since then. I am still not
fluent in Turkish, but I know that I can be. My mind is ready for it; I just
need to get some more vocabulary and colloquial expressions under my belt. I
feel so much more confident than when I arrived 4 months ago that this is
possible though. In turn this has confirmed one last point that I want to leave
you with. I know that I’ll be back to Turkey. Perhaps not this year or even the
next, but this nation has captured my heart and I know that no matter what, my
life trajectory with circle back to it, and to this city that I love. The life
of this city fills me with awe, lifts me up when I am down and gives me the
confidence to keep working. Görüşme üzere
Istanbul, until we meet again.
Hello, Hannah! I'm not sure my comment showed up so if you see it twice, I apologize!! I really enjoyed this post (will read more as I get time! Elaina told us about your blog at the beginning of her Turkey experience), it was very well-written! I enjoyed your thoughtful comparison of societal attitudes between America and Turkey regarding time vs. the person--we Americans ARE sadly very time-conscious! My husband and I enjoy travelling for the very reason to experience other cultures and to try to show being a "good" American tourist (understanding, acceptance, meeting others at least halfway, trying to learn their language) and not a self-centered, demanding tourist. I also really enjoyed the illustration about the buddies seeing off their friend, I too would have been nervous at an unexpected noisy gathering late at night! Excellent writing, again--you will need to be a writer in some fashion no matter what your career!
ReplyDelete